Glossary entry (derived from question below)
German term or phrase:
Quellenwert
English translation:
value as source material
Added to glossary by
Chris Rowson (X)
Jun 19, 2003 06:08
21 yrs ago
German term
Quellenwert
German to English
Art/Literary
Music
musicology
"Obgleich die Mehrzahl der Kompositionen in Berlin sicherlich leicht zu beschaffen war, stellt sich doch die Frage, ob Possin nicht direkt auf Manuskripte aus C. P. E. Bachs Notenbibliothek zurückgreifen konnte, so dass seinen Kopien in einzelnen Fällen ein sehr hoher Quellenwert zugestanden werden muss."
Anyone up on musicological expressions in English? I confess to having been involved in the practice in the past, but I have been largely clean for some time now. I am nevertheless still able to understand what is being said here, but I can´t think of an appropriate English phrasing.
Anyone up on musicological expressions in English? I confess to having been involved in the practice in the past, but I have been largely clean for some time now. I am nevertheless still able to understand what is being said here, but I can´t think of an appropriate English phrasing.
Proposed translations
(English)
4 +1 | value as source material | heikeb |
4 +4 | must be considered a very valuable (or reliable) source | William Stein |
4 | a reliable source text | blomguib (X) |
Proposed translations
+1
45 mins
Selected
value as source material
cf:
In music, primary sources are first of all the scores—scores as nearly as possible in the form that the composer left them. In a study of performance, records [or any recordings] are also primary sources. Other kinds of primary sources are letters of a composer; an autobiography or a biography written from personal acquaintance and not from other writings; articles in newspapers and magazines from the time of the events reported— also criticism, programs, advertisements, etc. (In some cases, notably Bach, Handel, Mozart, and Schubert, such materials have been assembled and gathered into “documentary biographies”—this does not take away from their value as source material.)
http://www.elmhurst.edu/~markh/history2/FullerPapers.htm
consisting of reports and notes from 17th century inventories of archaeological remains and historical monuments. These inventories are of significant value as source material for archaeologists and art-historians.
http://www.kb.se/HS/Eng/Aldre.htm
Philological study of the source texts is necessary to establish their date and nature as texts, and thus their value as source materials for the historian.
http://www.umass.edu/wsp/methodology/philology/summary.html
In music, primary sources are first of all the scores—scores as nearly as possible in the form that the composer left them. In a study of performance, records [or any recordings] are also primary sources. Other kinds of primary sources are letters of a composer; an autobiography or a biography written from personal acquaintance and not from other writings; articles in newspapers and magazines from the time of the events reported— also criticism, programs, advertisements, etc. (In some cases, notably Bach, Handel, Mozart, and Schubert, such materials have been assembled and gathered into “documentary biographies”—this does not take away from their value as source material.)
http://www.elmhurst.edu/~markh/history2/FullerPapers.htm
consisting of reports and notes from 17th century inventories of archaeological remains and historical monuments. These inventories are of significant value as source material for archaeologists and art-historians.
http://www.kb.se/HS/Eng/Aldre.htm
Philological study of the source texts is necessary to establish their date and nature as texts, and thus their value as source materials for the historian.
http://www.umass.edu/wsp/methodology/philology/summary.html
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer.
Comment: "Thanks everyone. I actually wound up using a translation derived from "assigning a high ranking as source material", but Heike´s answer led me to it, and I think it would in general be the best."
+4
2 mins
must be considered a very valuable (or reliable) source
I think it takes a good deal of rephrasing
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2003-06-19 07:12:56 (GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
\"authenticity\" might be another possibility
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2003-06-19 07:12:56 (GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
\"authenticity\" might be another possibility
Peer comment(s):
agree |
Stultitia Au (X)
4 mins
|
agree |
Lucyna Długołęcka
6 mins
|
agree |
Rowan Morrell
: Sounds pretty good.
13 mins
|
agree |
Сергей Лузан
21 mins
|
12 mins
a reliable source text
is how I would put it
Something went wrong...