German term
wissenschaftlicher Mitarbeiter
This question has been asked before, but the answers don't really satisfy me.
I'm asking myself how to properly translate the German job-description of "wissenschaftlicher Mitarbeiter" in English. It's a position at a university that usually involves research, lecturing as well as the writing of a doctoral thesis if the researcher has not achieved his/her Ph.D. yet.
In my understanding the correct translation might differ depending on the academic degree of the "wissenschaftlicher Mitarbeiter" (i.e. already achieved Ph.D. or not).
However, I think "Research Associate" might be a correct translation in any circumstance, whereas "Research Assistant" might be more suitable for "wissenschaftliche Hilfskraft".
Or how about "Researcher" "Research fellow"?
What do you guys think?
Best regards,
Franky
Info |
Kim Metzger
![]() |
Nov 8, 2009 12:53: Steffen Walter changed "Field" from "Other" to "Science" , "Field (specific)" from "Science (general)" to "Human Resources"
Proposed translations
Lecturer (UK); Assistant Professor (US)
agree |
Harald Moelzer (medical-translator)
1 hr
|
Thanks, Harald.
|
|
agree |
TonyTK
: It all depends on the context. At the university here in Germany where I teach a few hours a week, these people are often simply full-time lecturers who do little or no research.
5 hrs
|
Thanks, Tony.
|
|
agree |
Na Nandhorn Clauder
8 hrs
|
Thanks, njclauder.
|
|
neutral |
Sabine Akabayov, PhD
: this term exludes all natural sciences
1 day 8 hrs
|
research associate
agree |
Richard McGowan
: Forget about "Researcher" or "Research fellow". "Research Associate" sounds much more distinct.
10 mins
|
Did you mean to refer to "research associate"? I had ruled out the "assistant" in my answer for the reasons stated above.
|
|
agree |
Ingrid Moore
1 hr
|
agree |
John Speese
: I too would say research associate; as indeed the exact Eng. lang. title would depend on the degree, whether or not the person is tenured, and on the country. The US and British systems are different. I might even add the Ger. title in brackets.
6 hrs
|
neutral |
Kim Metzger
: Wikipedia: Research assistants (in some institutions referred to as Research Officer) are often enrolled in a higher degree (e.g. Masters or Ph.D.) programme.
7 hrs
|
You live and learn :-)
|
Junior Lecturer
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 50 mins (2009-11-08 13:33:38 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
I ashould add if this text is aimed at the US, then quite a different translation might be best around their system of Assistent and Associate Professorships etc.
Post-doc research fellow/doctoral research assistant [ see expl.]
I'd go with "doctoral research assistant" if working towards a PhD and "research fellow", possibly also "post-doc research fellow" if already a PhD.
research scientist
Typical work activities of a Research Scientist:
The exact nature of the work depends on the level of seniority of a research post, the specific area of life sciences studied and also whether the context is industrial or academic. However, most life science researchers are involved in the following:
* devising and conducting experiments;
* processing and analysing results and data;
* communicating results to the scientific community via published papers;
* collaborating with industry/academia to apply the results of research and develop new techniques, products or practices;
* presenting ongoing work and findings to colleagues at academic conferences, and producing academic posters which summarise the nature of their research, their methodology and their findings;
* carrying out field work to inform their research;
* teaching, demonstrating or supervising students (in academia) and training and supervising other members of staff;
* devising or helping to draw up new research proposals and applying for funding and grants;
* working in multidisciplinary teams (in academia, across different faculties or schools, and in industry, across different functions of the business).
http://209.85.229.132/search?q=cache:NkSoOERgxTYJ:www.prospe...
Almost every aspect of our lives, from medicine to mobile phone technology, is influenced by the work of research scientists. They work in a wide range of scientific fields including biology, biochemistry, chemistry, ecology, environmental biology, forensic science and genetics. In the course of their work they plan and conduct experiments, analysing results and making predictions based on their findings. They devise and test ways of applying new discoveries to make things faster, safer, more efficient, cheaper, more effective or more environmentally friendly. Scientists working in the natural world collect samples, monitor environmental factors such as sea levels or pollution and study plants and animals in their natural habitat.
http://209.85.229.132/search?q=cache:kxeqTXfbBf0J:www.connex...
Postdoctoral Research Scientist
Cancer Metabolomics
The Beatson Institute for Cancer Research
The Beatson Institute in Glasgow is one of Europe's leading cancer research centres. It is core funded by Cancer Research UK and supports cutting edge research into the molecular mechanisms of cancer development. The Institute has recently moved to a new facility that provides an outstanding research environment, underpinned by state-of-the-art core services and advanced technologies.
Postdoctoral Research Scientist
Cancer Metabolomics
The Beatson Institute for Cancer Research
Starting Salary from £25,500 to £33,000 (Depending on experience)
Initial 1 year fixed term contract
The Beatson Institute in Glasgow is one of Europe's leading cancer research centres. It is core funded by Cancer Research UK and supports cutting edge research into the molecular mechanisms of cancer development. The Institute has recently moved to a new facility that provides an outstanding research environment, underpinned by state-of-the-art core services and advanced technologies.
disagree |
Kim Metzger
: This term would rule out the social sciences and other academic fields.
6 hrs
|
As far as I am aware and what I found, this term would also cover social sciences and other academic fields.
|
academic associate
disagree |
Kim Metzger
: The term "academic associate" seems to be associated primarily with medicine http://www.answers.com/topic/academic-associates
5 hrs
|
Research Fellow
Reference comments
Info
The title of research associate is used to denote an academic research position at a university or similar institution. A research associate usually conducts research under the supervision of a principal investigator. In contrast to a research assistant or research officer, a research associate often has a doctoral degree or carried out an equivalent work. In some cases it can be synonymous with postdoctoral research.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Research_associate
A Research Assistant is a junior graduate, employed on a temporary contract by a college or university or a research institute, for the purpose of academic research. Research assistants are not independent and not responsible for the out-come of the research and are responsible to a supervisor or Principal Investigator.
Research assistants (in some institutions referred to as Research Officer) are often enrolled in a higher degree (e.g. Masters or Ph.D.) programme. In research institutions without graduate programmes, research assistants positions are typically for graduates who are gaining research experience on short term contracts.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Research_assistant
The title of research fellow is used to denote a research position at a university or similar institution, usually for academic staff or faculty members. A research fellow may act as independent investigator, or under the supervision of a principal investigator. In contrast to a research assistant or research officer, the position of research fellow, normally requires a doctoral degree or equivalent work.
In the United Kingdom, at many universities, this position is the first career grade of a Research Career Pathway and may be permanent, subject to normal probation regulations. Within such a path, the next two higher career grades are usually senior research fellow and professorial fellow. Although similar to the position of a research fellow, these two positions are research only posts, with the rise of the career grade there will normally be a formal requirement of a moderate amount of teaching and/or supervision (often at postgraduate level). These positions are for researchers with a proven track record of generating research income to fund themselves and producing high quality research output that is internationally recognised.
In North America, a research fellow is often a Post-doctoral fellow, who undertakes research in addition to doctoral research. Alternatively a research fellow may be a visiting research fellow from another institution, who tends to be at a more senior career level. There are also faculty research fellow (FRF), being a faculty member without tenure.
Germany
The English term research fellow is sometimes used to refer to the holder of a research fellowship from a public foundation that promotes research. Fellowships, form prestigous institutions such as Alexander von Humboldt Foundation, can be obtained by postdoctoral researchers at the beginning of their academic career, by experienced, established scholars and scientists, or even leading authorities in their discipline[1]. This means that the award holder may formally hold a specific title at his or her home institution (e.g. Privatdozent), but may in the context of the sponsor be refer to as research fellow
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Research_fellow
Discussion
Kim, I'm primarily looking for the British Englisch word, but to know what it is in US English wouldn't hurt of course.
Steffen, I think you're right. What makes me hesitant to use "research associate" is what Kim postes as a reference comment as well as what Donal posted: I was told that the founding source makes a difference indeed, too.
In Germany, we don't have the distinction between funding source or academic degree: they're all "wissenschaftlicher Mitarbeiter". Similary, I am looking for a "safe bet" (as Steffen described it) without being incorrect. Basically, I am assuming that the position is research oriented, involves lecturing and is funded by the university.
So far, I would thus go with "research associate" or "(Junior) Lecturer" - but I think the discussion shows that there are quite a few different views, all of which have valid points.
Any other comments?