Jan 3, 2006 22:44
18 yrs ago
34 viewers *
English term

do not need vs. need not

English Other Other english grammar
Hi. To make long things short, I was told that the correct use of need was "need not" (e.g., noblemen need not pay taxes). However, it is becoming more and more common the expression "do not need" (e.g., you don't need lead to make gold). A "google fight" comes up with what is almost a draw: 46MM to the first use, and 36MM to the second.
Which is the correct one?
Change log

Jan 3, 2006 23:05: Walter Landesman changed "Language pair" from "English to Spanish" to "English"

Jan 4, 2006 02:52: Brie Vernier changed "Level" from "Non-PRO" to "PRO"

Votes to reclassify question as PRO/non-PRO:

PRO (3): Сергей Лузан, Nick Lingris, Brie Vernier

When entering new questions, KudoZ askers are given an opportunity* to classify the difficulty of their questions as 'easy' or 'pro'. If you feel a question marked 'easy' should actually be marked 'pro', and if you have earned more than 20 KudoZ points, you can click the "Vote PRO" button to recommend that change.

How to tell the difference between "easy" and "pro" questions:

An easy question is one that any bilingual person would be able to answer correctly. (Or in the case of monolingual questions, an easy question is one that any native speaker of the language would be able to answer correctly.)

A pro question is anything else... in other words, any question that requires knowledge or skills that are specialized (even slightly).

Another way to think of the difficulty levels is this: an easy question is one that deals with everyday conversation. A pro question is anything else.

When deciding between easy and pro, err on the side of pro. Most questions will be pro.

* Note: non-member askers are not given the option of entering 'pro' questions; the only way for their questions to be classified as 'pro' is for a ProZ.com member or members to re-classify it.

Discussion

Marcelo González Jan 3, 2006:
It might be better to post this (and similar questions) under "English monolingual." Good luck, germanpenn :-)

Responses

+8
2 hrs
Selected

You probably don't need such a long explanation, but you needn't worry - you can always skip it.

Try to distinguish between need + object and need + verb.

Need + object is always a full verb, like 'want'.
e.g.
I need a drink. | The remote control needs new batteries. | You don't need lead to make gold. (Strange example, but this is where it belongs.) | I need glasses for reading.

Need + verb can also be a full verb. As a full verb it is usually followed by to-infinitive.
e.g.
He needs to see a doctor straightaway. | You need to let me know by Monday if you want to take part.
Fortunately I didn't need to pay for it. = I didn't have to pay for it. (i.e. I didn't pay) – but see 'I needn't have paid' below.

One exception to the 'need+to-infinitive' pattern is when 'need' is followed by –ing. This –ing verb has a passive meaning (same as want –ing).
e.g.
Does this shirt need ironing? = Does this shirt need to be ironed?
The plants need watering once a week. = The plants need to be watered…

Need is also a modal verb, like 'must': no –s in the third singular, no 'do' in questions and negatives, no past forms. And always followed by another verb (bare infinitive, i.e. infinitive without 'to'). In this respect, its main difference from 'must' is that we do not use it in affirmative sentences (unless with restrictive adverbs such as 'hardly' or 'only').
e.g.
We needn't stay long.
Need we leave so soon?
She's lazy, slow, and stubborn. Need I say more?
He need never find out what I said.
I need hardly remind you that this information is confidential.
We need only look at the building to see how much money it will take to repair.

Note its use with a perfect infinitive (i.e. have done sth):
I needn't have paid for it. (i.e. Unfortunately, I paid for it. Note the difference from "I didn't need to pay for it".)
[Most of the above examples taken from the Longman Dictionary of Contemporary English.]

The use of the modal in questions and negatives is more common in British English and a bit old-fashioned.
Whoever told you that "it is becoming more and more common to use 'do not need'" was referring to "needn't do" being replaced by "don't need to do" (though "don't have to do" is even more common).

Your second example (You don't need lead to make gold, i.e. need+noun) never created problems or doubts and has nothing to do with the modal 'need'.

Your first example (Noblemen need not pay taxes) is also fine. See this article entitled "Nobles need not pay taxes" (http://www.commondreams.org/views05/0201-23.htm) based on something written by Marc Bloch.
It would be equally correct to say "Noblemen do not need to pay taxes" but much more common to say "Noblemen do not have to pay taxes".
Peer comment(s):

agree Brie Vernier : Very well put, Nick. The two expressions need not (!) "convey precisely the same idea" and most certainly can have very different meanings.
1 hr
Thank you very much, Brie.
agree Refugio : Agree that there are shades of difference in meaning.
8 hrs
Thank you, Ruth. And all the best!
agree cmwilliams (X)
8 hrs
Thanks, cm! All the best in the new year!
agree Marina56 : ok
9 hrs
Thank you, Marina. Happy 2006!
agree juvera
11 hrs
Thanks, Judith, and happy 2006!
agree Rachel Fell
13 hrs
Thanks, Rachel.
agree Christine Andersen : This explains it well - I didn't need to think it all out for myself ;-)
15 hrs
;-}} Thanks!
agree Vicky Papaprodromou
16 hrs
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Thanx a lot. Very clear and straightforward. Additional thanx to all other experts who participated in this Q."
9 mins

explanation

Here there are a couple of explanations with examples

v.aux.

To be under the necessity of or the obligation to: They need not come.
v.tr.

To have need of; require: The family needs money. See synonyms

There you can find some notes on usage.
Good luck
Peer comment(s):

neutral Richard Benham : This doesn't even address the question.
9 hrs
Something went wrong...
-1
16 mins

explanation

need not (British) (Also used as modal meaning must not)
do not need (standard)
Peer comment(s):

neutral Marcelo González : "Need not" is NOT British; it's English, used on both sides of the Atlantic, as well as in the South Pacific (as our aussie and kiwi colleagues can surely attest). Happy New Year from the US!
26 mins
disagree Richard Benham : Also, "need not" must not be used for "must not".
8 hrs
Something went wrong...
+1
18 mins

see

1) Need: means "to require" as a normal verb that forms it`s interrogative and negative with do/does/did, and is also used as an auxiliary verb.
Need to / Don't need to
Needed to / Didn't need to

Ex. My hair needs cutting. / I don't need a rest.
I needed to get new tyres for my car. / I didn't need to tell him the truth.

2) Need: means "have to" as a special finite; it's defective, having only the one form. The 3rd. person singular present tense does not take -s. It forms it's interrogative form by inversion and it's negative by adding -not (needn't). It can make question phrases and can be followed by plain infinitive (without -to).
It's not used in affirmative sentences, only interrogative and negative ones. The affirmative is replaced by MUST or equivalents.
Ex.
Need he work so hard?
You needn't go yet, need you?
You needn't see him, but I must.

I can be used affirmatively with adverbs sucha as NEVER, HARDLY, etc. with negative implications.
The past tense is NEED...HAVE.
Ex.
Need you have scolded him so severely?

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 23 mins (2006-01-03 23:07:53 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

HOPE IT HELPS!
You do not need: You do not require
You need not do it: You do not have to do it

Peer comment(s):

agree Walter Landesman
4 mins
GRACIAS!
neutral Richard Benham : You have not answered the question.
8 hrs
I did my best to help the asker.
Something went wrong...
+4
2 hrs

both are correct

It isn't really a question of which one is "correct" since both are grammatically correct. I think the choice of which to use depends on the sentence, though there is certainly no difference in meaning, to my mind.

In colloquial speech in the UK I rarely hear "need not", though the contaction "needn't" does crop up from time to time, e.g.

"Shall I phone to let you know when they've arrived?"
"You needn't bother" ( = you do not need to bother)

Saying "you don't need to bother" would be perfectly correct, however.

I tend to come across "need not" more often in written English. One phrase which immediately leaps to mind is:

"Previous applicants need not reapply" (a polite way of saying "if you've tried applying to us before, we don't want to hear from you again!")

The short answer to your question, though, is that both are correct. I would only add that "need not" is probably less common in colloquial speech, and even then it is often contracted to "needn't".
Peer comment(s):

agree Marcelo González : Both are correct, which is precisely the point I've made above. It has nothing to do with notions of correctness, and everything to do with usage (in different contexts). Happy New Year!
16 mins
thanks - and happy New Year to you!
agree Sophia Finos (X)
1 hr
thanks
agree Richard Benham
6 hrs
thanks
neutral Refugio : Both are correct, but are often used differently.
8 hrs
agree Rachel Fell
13 hrs
Something went wrong...
+2
52 mins

"need not" is more unequivocal when a specific meaning is intended

In my opinion, "do not need to" may mean several things, while "need not" only is more unequivocal, and that is why it may be preferred in certain situations.

"does not need to" may mean:
1. is not required to
2. has no need to

while "need not" - I THINK - only means "not required to".


--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 3 hrs 22 mins (2006-01-04 02:07:14 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

(I'm sorry - you probably have enough reading material already!)
Just to demonstrate my point:
You can ALWAYS say "not need to", but you can only say "need not to" in specific cases.
E.g. You can say "I don't need to sleep now", but you can't say "I need not sleep" (when "need" = "have a need to")
Peer comment(s):

agree Richard Benham : I think you have a point, although further distinctions might need to be made.
8 hrs
agree Marina56 : ok
11 hrs
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search